Airflow Study of Temporary Buildings in Barrow, Alaska

(Dave Rogers, NCAR/RAF - Nov. 23, 2008)
Problem Description
Air chemistry sampling instruments will be installed in two portable buildings at a Barrow Alaska site during February and March 2009.  The instruments will have inlet piping that extends a short distance outside of the building walls into the ambient air.  A flow modeling study was performed to assess the likelihood that the building walls might contaminate the samples. This is especially important for measurements of reactive gases.
Site Map
Wind climatology report
Portable buildings are 14'x20'x12' tall, supported on 12" high skids.
end photo
side photo
Flow Modeling Approach
The portable buildings are modeled in Gambit as relatively simple arrangement of flat planes that represent the basic geometry.  There are two buildings. Their long axes are at a 71° angle, and their closest separation is 14'. One building is north of the other. They are placed in a flow domain that is 200' along the x-axis (mean wind direction), 200' wide and 40' tall. In order to vary the direction of the ambient wind, the upwind boundary face is defined by an elliptical arc. The downwind boundary is a flat face. The computational grid is a tetrahedral-hybrid unstructured mesh, with an initial size of 0.2' on the building surfaces. The grid spacing expands exponentially to 1.0' when 5' from the buildings and reaches a maximum of 5' when 30' or further from the buildings.  The domain has a total of 1,547,167 cells.
(click on images to see grid)
Boundary conditions are representative of the Barrow climatology in February and March, temperature -23°C.  The ambient wind is steady 6.0 m/s, and three simulations are done for wind directions 060°,  075° and 090°. FLUENT is used to solve for the flow, assuming 3D steady-state, incompressible conditions. The Spalart-Allmaras scheme is used to represent turbulence.
The approach describe here produces useful results but fails to account for surface roughness, vertical shear at the domain edges, heat transfer or convection, variations in wind speed or direction. It does not account for static stability in the temperature profile that is typical for polar regions in winter. The top of the domain is modeled unrealistically as a rigid wall at 40', but is sufficiently far from the region of interest that it probably doesn't matter for the purposes of this study.

Results

Flow simulations were done for three directions of ambient wind. Contour and vector plots were generated on a horizontal surface 2 m above the ground. This is the approximate height where air sample inlets will be place on the sides of the buildings. Plots showing local vectors reveal recirculation regions in the lee areas of the buildings.  In the following plots, the x-axis is aligned with the mean wind direction, 075° clockwise from true north.
The general result suggests that sampling on the upwind faces of the buildings (NE or SE faces) is unlikely to be affected by contamination from the building. Regions on the downwind side will be affected by vertical mixing and recirculation, including some flow from beneath or above the buildings.
Click on links in the table to see the plots.
velocity contour velocity
zoom
vectors around north building zoom south building vectors around
south
building
zoom north building
vertical
velocities
turbulence turbulence
zoom
060° 060° 060° 060° 060° 060° 060°
075° 075° 075° 075° 075° 075° 075° 075° 075°
090° 090° 090° 090° 090° 090° 090°

Path Lines

For the 075° wind case, path lines were constructed to show air trajectories leading to the sample probes 20" upwind from the faces of the buildings.  These probe areas are approximated as two small rectangular areas about 0.5 m square and located 2.0 m above ground level. Paths were traced backwards from them to the edge of the flow domain. The air that ultimately reaches the probes is 1.2 to 1.6 m above ground at the domain boundary, 30 m upwind.  Most of the vertical transport occurs within 5 m of the buildings.
top view
zoom NORTH bldg
zoom SOUTH bldg
perspective view
looking downwind
zoom NORTH bldg
zoom SOUTH bldg
height of path lines
zoom near building